Brighton Butler Divorce: What is the Current Status of Their Divorce Case?

By James Mercado On Sep 10, 2023

Brighton Butler is a famous fashion blogger and influencer who has amassed a loyal following of over 1.2 million on Instagram. She is known for her chic and trendy style, as well as her lifestyle and travel posts. She married Duncan Butler, a successful entrepreneur and investor, in 2019, and they have two children together: Harper and Hudson.

However, their seemingly perfect marriage came to an abrupt end when Brighton filed for divorce on May 2, 2023, shocking her fans and the public. Since then, the couple has been embroiled in a complex and contentious legal battle over their assets, custody, and alimony. Here are some of the most frequently asked questions about their divorce and the answers based on the available information.

Why Did Brighton Butler File for Divorce?

According to the divorce petition filed by Brighton Butler, she cited “irreconcilable differences” as the reason for the dissolution of their marriage. She also claimed that Duncan Butler had been unfaithful to her multiple times during their relationship and that he had a history of substance abuse and domestic violence. She alleged that he had physically assaulted her on several occasions, leaving her with bruises and scars. She also accused him of being verbally and emotionally abusive, controlling, and manipulative.

Brighton Butler also stated that she had tried to save their marriage by attending counseling sessions with Duncan Butler, but he had refused to cooperate or change his behavior. She said that she had lost trust and respect for him and that she feared for her safety and the well-being of their children. She requested sole legal and physical custody of their children, as well as spousal support and attorney fees.

How Did Duncan Butler Respond to the Divorce Petition?

Duncan Butler filed a response to the divorce petition on June 12, 2023, denying all the allegations made by Brighton Butler. He claimed that he had been a loving and faithful husband and that he had never abused or cheated on her. He also said that he had been supportive of her career and personal growth and that he had provided a comfortable and luxurious lifestyle for their family.

Duncan Butler also argued that Brighton Butler had been the one who had been unfaithful to him and that she had been involved in several affairs with other men. He said that she had been neglecting their children and spending too much time on social media and traveling. He requested joint legal and physical custody of their children, as well as an equitable division of their assets. He also asked the court to deny any spousal support or attorney fees to Brighton Butler.

Take a look at some additional recently published content from us:

What Are the Main Issues in Their Divorce Case?

The main issues in their divorce case are the division of their assets, the custody of their children, and the amount of spousal support. The couple has a prenuptial agreement that was signed before their marriage, but both parties have disputed its validity and enforceability. The prenuptial agreement stipulates that each party will retain their separate property and income and that neither party will pay or receive any alimony in case of divorce.

However, Brighton Butler has challenged the prenuptial agreement, claiming that it was signed under duress and coercion and that it is unconscionable and unfair. She has also argued that some of the assets acquired during their marriage should be considered community property, such as their mansion in Beverly Hills, their vacation home in Aspen, their yacht, their private jet, and their art collection. She has estimated their net worth to be over $500 million.

Duncan Butler has defended the prenuptial agreement, claiming that it was signed voluntarily and with full disclosure and that it is valid and binding. He has also argued that all the assets acquired during their marriage are his separate property since he was the sole source of income and wealth in their family. He has disputed Brighton Butler’s estimation of their net worth, saying that it is exaggerated and inflated.

The custody of their children is another contentious issue in their divorce case. Brighton Butler has requested sole custody of Harper and Hudson, saying that Duncan Butler is unfit to be a parent due to his infidelity, substance abuse, and violence. She has also expressed concern about his mental health and stability. She has asked for supervised visitation rights for Duncan Butler.

Duncan Butler has requested joint custody of Harper and Hudson, saying that he loves them dearly and wants to be involved in their lives. He has denied any wrongdoing or impairment in his parenting abilities. He has also accused Brighton Butler of alienating him from his children and poisoning them against him. He has asked for equal parenting time with Brighton Butler.

The amount of spousal support is another major issue in their divorce case. Brighton Butler has requested spousal support from Duncan Butler, saying that she needs it to maintain the standard of living that she was accustomed to during their marriage. She has also claimed that she sacrificed her career and education opportunities to support Duncan Butler’s endeavors and to raise their children. She has asked for $250,000 per month in spousal support.

Duncan Butler has opposed any spousal support to Brighton Butler, saying that she does not need it or deserve it. He has also claimed that she has her own income and assets from her fashion blog and endorsements and that she can support herself. He has also argued that she did not contribute to his success or wealth and that she wasted their money on frivolous and extravagant expenses. He has asked the court to terminate any spousal support obligation.

Brighton Butler shared some pictures with her kids on Instagram:

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Brighton Butler (@brightonbutler)

What is the Current Status of Their Divorce Case?

Their divorce case is still pending in the Los Angeles Superior Court, and no trial date has been set yet. The couple has been engaged in a series of hearings, motions, and discovery processes, as well as mediation and settlement talks. However, no agreement has been reached so far, and the case seems to be headed for a long and bitter litigation.

The couple has also been involved in a public feud, with both parties releasing statements and interviews to the media, as well as posting on social media. They have also been accused of leaking confidential information and documents to the press, as well as spreading rumors and lies about each other. Their divorce case has attracted a lot of attention and speculation from the public, as well as criticism and sympathy from their fans and followers.

What Are the Possible Outcomes of Their Divorce Case?

The possible outcomes of their divorce case depend on the evidence, arguments, and decisions presented by both parties and the court. The court will have to determine the validity and enforceability of the prenuptial agreement, the division of their assets, the custody of their children, and the amount of spousal support, based on the applicable laws and principles of equity and justice.

The best-case scenario for both parties would be to reach a mutually agreeable settlement that would avoid a costly and protracted trial. However, given the complexity and animosity of their case, this seems unlikely at this point. The worst-case scenario for both parties would be to lose in court and face unfavorable outcomes that would affect their finances, reputation, and relationship with their children.

The most likely scenario for both parties would be to compromise on some issues and concede on others, resulting in a mixed outcome that would reflect the strengths and weaknesses of their case. However, this would also depend on their willingness and ability to negotiate and cooperate with each other, as well as the guidance and intervention of the court.

Conclusion

Brighton Butler’s divorce is one of the most sensational and controversial celebrity divorces in recent history. It involves a famous fashion blogger and influencer, Brighton Butler, who filed for divorce from her husband, Duncan Butler, a successful entrepreneur and investor, on May 2, 2023. The couple has two children together: Harper and Hudson.

The main issues in their divorce case are the division of their assets, the custody of their children, and the amount of spousal support. The couple has a prenuptial agreement that was signed before their marriage, but both parties have disputed its validity and enforceability. The couple has also been engaged in a public feud, with both parties releasing statements and interviews to the media, as well as posting on social media.

Their divorce case is still pending in the Los Angeles Superior Court, and no trial date has been set yet. The possible outcomes of their divorce case depend on the evidence, arguments, and decisions presented by both parties and the court. The best-case scenario for both parties would be to reach a mutually agreeable settlement that would avoid a costly and protracted trial.

The worst-case scenario for both parties would be to lose in court and face unfavorable outcomes that would affect their finances, reputation, and relationship with their children. The most likely scenario for both parties would be to compromise on some issues and concede on others, resulting in a mixed outcome that would reflect the strengths and weaknesses of their case.

Contents